Skip to main content
Karoline S. Nowillo, MD

Karoline S. Nowillo, MD

Optum Provider

Specialty

Plastic Surgery

Languages

English, Spanish

Seeing patients at

Patient Reviews

Patient review summary

Learn about our survey

5

4

3

2

1

4.7

12 reviews

    • Reviewed on Jun 16, 2026
    • Verified Review

    Very professional and thorough

    • Reviewed on Jun 15, 2026
    • Verified Review

    She is a caring surgeon who thoroughly explained various issues.

    • Reviewed on Jun 11, 2026
    • Verified Review

    She’s amazing. Took the time to walk me through everything before and after surgery.

    • Reviewed on Jun 5, 2026
    • Verified Review

    Dr. Nowillo is compassionate, knowledgeable and extremely competent.

    • Reviewed on Mar 8, 2026
    • Verified Review

    The referring surgeon's office sent the wrong pathology report, and no one realized until I was in the procedure room for my surgery. I was becoming nervous about the amount of time it was taking to get the correct report and about the doctor being rushed to review it and perform my surgery. I felt much more at ease once Dr. Nowillo came to see me and review the report. Even though I had obviously become a speed bump in her day's schedule, she showed no signs of being bothered or in a hurry. She was kind and personable. She had credible self-confidence without arrogance, which made me feel I could trust her.

    • Reviewed on Mar 7, 2026
    • Verified Review

    She is amazing. Explains everything very deeply and detailed, did an amazing job.

    • Reviewed on Feb 9, 2026
    • Verified Review

    Very Attentive & Professional

    • Reviewed on Feb 4, 2026
    • Verified Review

    Dr. Nowillo cares and allows enough time for your care.

    • Reviewed on Jan 29, 2026
    • Verified Review

    Excellent surgery on face. Easy recovery.

    • Reviewed on Jan 20, 2026
    • Verified Review

    Very compassionate, explaining everything, did mot rush. Answered all my questions

    • Reviewed on Jan 7, 2026
    • Verified Review

    Dr. Nowillo has consistently demonstrated exceptional professionalism, courtesy, and empathy throughout my recovery process. Her compassionate and understanding nature has left a lasting impression on me. While I am disappointed that Optum will no longer cover my insurance, I remain hopeful that a positive resolution will be reached and they will reconsider their decision.

    • Reviewed on Dec 2, 2025
    • Verified Review

    Very understanding,would quickly get back to me if I had a question or concern post op and overall did a great job with my surgery.

  • About Karoline S. Nowillo, MD

    Dr. Karoline S. Nowillo, MD, is a board-certified plastic surgeon specializing in cosmetic and reconstructive surgery. She was recognized as a Forty Under Forty Award recipient by the Dutchess County Chamber of Commerce for her professional and community impact. She completed advanced training in reconstructive microsurgery at Memorial Sloan Kettering Cancer Center. Dr. Nowillo has received Forty Under Forty and Rising Star recognition.

    Philosophy of care

    She treats both pediatric and adult patients and applies the same level of precision and care to aesthetic procedures as she does to complex reconstructive surgery. Dr. Nowillo has also volunteered internationally, providing surgical care to underserved children and families affected by congenital differences and burn injuries.

    Gender

    Female

    Licenses

    NY, 246259

    Network Name

    CareMount

    NPI

    1467688424

  • Insurance Accepted

    This list is for informational purposes only and may not reflect the most current plans accepted by the provider. Optum accepts most major health insurance plans. Please contact your insurance company to confirm your coverage, eligibility, and the provider's participation in your plan.

    • 1199
    • Aetna
    • Affinity
    • Anthem BCBS
    • CDPHP
    • CHN
    • Centivo
    • Cigna
    • Coventry
    • EmblemHealth
    • First Health
    • Healthfirst
    • Humana
    • MVP Healthcare
    • MagnaCare
    • Medicaid
    • Medicare
    • MetroPlus
    • MultiPlan
    • NYSHIP
    • Northwell Direct
    • Oscar
    • Oxford
    • TRICARE
    • UMR
  • Education

    Medical School

    • SUNY Downstate Medical Center

    Residency

    • Nassau County Medical Center (NuHealth)

  • Awards and Publications