Skip to main content
Informational

Your experience at our Optum NY location is important to us:

Need assistance or have concerns? The Optum leadership team is here to help.

Health care

We provide affordable and personalized care

How can we help?

Helpful links

Financial

Accounts to help you save and pay for health care expenses

How can we help?

Helpful links

  • Resources

    Find contribution limits, savings tools, calculators and eligible expenses

  • Account support

    Find contact information and frequently asked questions

Tax season resources

Get ready for HSA tax season

If you used an HSA this year, the HSA Tax Center offers general information about contributions, eligible expenses and commonly used tax forms — all in one place.

Pharmacy

We make it easy to get medications you need, when and where you need them

How can we help?

Helpful links

  • Optum Rx

    For people with pharmacy insurance benefits through Optum Rx

  • Track orders

    Track your home delivery and specialty order

  • Pharmacy support

    Find contact information and answers to frequently asked questions

Mobile app

Optum Rx on the go

Request refills, track order status, manage billing information and much more.

Download on the App StoreGet it on Google Play
John F. Rothar, MD

John F. Rothar, MD

Optum Provider

Specialty

Internal Medicine

Languages

English

Seeing patients at

Monday 8:00 AM - 6:00 PM
Tuesday 8:00 AM - 6:00 PM
Wednesday 8:00 AM - 3:00 PM
Thursday 8:00 AM - 6:00 PM
Friday 8:00 AM - 3:00 PM
Sunday Closed
Please contact the clinic directly to schedule and confirm appointment availability.

Patient Reviews

Patient review summary

Learn about our survey

5

4

3

2

1

4.9

73 reviews

  • Mar 27, 2026
    Verified Review

    He is an excellent doctor - very knowledgable and caring!

  • Mar 26, 2026
    Verified Review

    Very thorough pleasant and knowledgeable.

  • Mar 25, 2026
    Verified Review

    took the time in examing me and going over my history as this was the first appt i ever had with him..

  • Mar 22, 2026
    Verified Review

    At the age of [omitted] he is the big part of my good health

  • Mar 21, 2026
    Verified Review

    He is very courteous and he answers all of concerns I may have about my health and well being. And informs me of what my medical needs are in a non aggressive manner

  • Mar 17, 2026
    Verified Review

    He is professional,caring,knowledgeable friendly and prompt

  • Mar 17, 2026
    Verified Review

    Thorough and professional

  • Mar 16, 2026
    Verified Review

    i had Dr Hantverk before his retirement and he came highly recommended by him. I met Dr Rothar for the first time on my last visit and everything was as Dr Hantverk said he would be.

  • Mar 16, 2026
    Verified Review

    His been my Head Doctor for over 30 years, and always provided me with excellent , advice and follow ups.

  • Mar 14, 2026
    Verified Review

    Dr Rothar is very skilled, knowledgeable and proactive regarding my care. Have been a patient of his for 20+ years.

  • Mar 12, 2026
    Verified Review

    He is a great doctor and I have a great relationship with him

  • Mar 11, 2026
    Verified Review

    Very easy to converse with and is quite caring.

  • Mar 2, 2026
    Verified Review

    He is very thorough and cares deeply about his patients.

  • Feb 27, 2026
    Verified Review

    He is the best pc I ever had, he is always been very attentive to my medical needs and always gives the perfect specialist referral if needed

  • Feb 25, 2026
    Verified Review

    I felt Dr. Rothar was very informative and compassionate regarding my history

  • Feb 24, 2026
    Verified Review

    Very simple DR Rother is an amazing Dr he truly car's for his pachents been going to DR rother for meany years don't think I would go to another doctor.

  • Feb 21, 2026
    Verified Review

    Good doctor who is thorough and answers all questions

  • Feb 20, 2026
    Verified Review

    Dr. Rothar is extremely knowledgeable. I saw two specialists before seeing Dr .Rothar and he was able to answer questions with confidence that the specialists seemed unsure about.

  • Feb 14, 2026
    Verified Review

    Dr Rothar cares about You. He wants to make sure your in your best health. He also wants info from other drs, and mammos etc. This gives him the best all around of your health.

  • Feb 9, 2026
    Verified Review

    My first visit with him.

Page 1 of 4
  • About John F. Rothar, MD

    Dr. John F. Rothar is a board certified internist with a focus on preventive health. He completed medical training at SUNY Brooklyn and advanced residency training at Cornell, North Shore University Hospital, and Memorial Sloan Kettering, serving as Chief Resident.

    Philosophy of care

    Dr. Rothar emphasizes prevention, early intervention, and partnership to support long-term wellness.

    Gender

    Male

    Board certifications

    American Board of Internal Medicine

    Licenses

    NY, 206318

    Employed or contracted

    Employed

    Network Name

    ProHealth

    NPI

    1770585093

  • Insurance accepted

    This may not reflect all insurance accepted by the provider and is for informational purposes only.

    • 1199
    • Aetna
    • Affinity
    • Anthem BCBS
    • CHN
    • Centivo
    • Cigna
    • Coventry
    • EmblemHealth
    • First Health
    • Humana
    • MagnaCare
    • Medicaid
    • Medicare
    • MultiPlan
    • NYSHIP
    • Northwell Direct
    • Oscar
    • Oxford
    • TRICARE
    • UHC
    • UMR
  • Medical School

    • State University of New York