Bringing the care back to our health care system
Rethinking our health care infrastructure and value system could bring physicians back to the heart of what they do.
The patient, a 65-year-old woman, has begun to notice two things: She’s gaining weight and, a little more troubling, there is a buildup of fluid in her leg. It doesn’t seem alarming enough to her to merit a visit to the emergency room or the cost of seeing her doctor, but as time passes she finds herself increasingly short of breath when walking. Still, she doesn’t feel the need to take serious action.
Then one night, she wakes up and realizes she’s more short of breath than she’s ever felt before. Frightened, she calls 911, and an ambulance races her to the hospital. There, in the intensive care unit, she is diagnosed with congestive heart failure (CHF). Once stabilized, she is sent home with a list of prescriptions. Three weeks later, she wakes up short of breath again, and the process repeats itself.
This case is unfortunately typical, and it doesn’t have to be. If this patient’s care had been managed by a more proactive, integrated, coordinated delivery system, the crisis that led her to the hospital, and the CHF itself, might have been avoided.
New technologies and a new approach to health care are combining to create a paradigm shift in America’s health care system. Particularly when applied to chronic conditions and to an aging population that is growing rapidly as the baby boomer generation retires, it’s a shift that couldn’t have come at a better time.
Such a shift begins at the center of care, with physicians. Though doctors across the country bear much of the cost and responsibility for improving patient care, many of them are not in a position to influence the structure and approach of their organizations. To many health care experts, that simply doesn’t make sense.
“Physicians can’t just stand on the sidelines. They have to be active participants in this process,” says Kurt Tamaru, M.D, chief clinical officer for OptumCare, a coordinated network of physicians and caregivers connected by technology. Under the umbrella of Optum, a health services and innovation leader, OptumCare provides resources that help doctors take better care of their patients. “We’re always thinking about things from the perspective of those physicians. How does this translate to that patient-doctor relationship? Does it inhibit or promote that relationship? We want to promote that relationship.”
Information is at the heart of that relationship. To truly establish a connection and partnership with their patients, physicians need to know what they need—ideally without asking them the same questions over and over each time they come to a doctor’s office. According to a survey conducted by the California HealthCare Foundation, about 40 percent of physicians reported that patients experienced problems because care wasn’t well coordinated among providers and sites.
A doctor needs to have access to a patient’s history and information: not only their health conditions, but also updates from their specialists, urgent-care team, and wellness advisors. Providers are increasingly applying technology and new thinking to the health care process that allows for central, up-to-date access to all that information and the time to help patients navigate the health care system.
Connected and data-driven through cutting-edge technology
Close integration among the many different channels of a modern health care delivery system is reliant on an electronic medical record (EMR) that aggregates input from multiple providers and incorporates the kind of high-level data analysis that can deliver insights about the health of communities and wider populations.
“You can do the best work but, at the end, not reach all your patients—not because of reimbursement, not because it’s not good technology, not because of coverage, but because of [lack of] health care systems connectivity,” one Medtech executive told Deloitte in a report on medical innovation.
Some health care network providers have been using integrated systems of their own for years, but not all of them have been taking advantage of the opportunity for deep, longitudinal medical analysis on the level of both populations and individual patients. By combining long-term, one-to-one physician-patient relationships with a proactive population-health approach that looks at systemic trends, providers would be able to offer what Charles Staub, M.D, chairman of OptumCare’s ProHealth Physicians, describes as “whole-person care on the individual level and whole-population care at the larger level.”
Consider, for example, a region where 175 people have been diagnosed with diabetes, 50 of whom remain uncontrolled based on recent blood testing. Sophisticated, population-focused data analysis might then be able to predict that, left unaddressed, 10 of these patients have a 90 percent chance of being admitted to the hospital in the next 90 days. The electronic system could then automatically notify the patients’ primary-care physician of this possibility, pull those patients in for appointments with their doctors, and ultimately prevent some of those hospitalizations.
The more a network like this expands, the more powerful those population-level data analytics become, and providers clearly see the opportunity: A survey in 2013 found that 66 percent of health systems planned to improve their population-health strategies through data analytics.
Backed and ensured by a value-based model
What is motivating this change in approach? One driver is 2010 Affordable Care Act, which has brought more than 16 million Americans into the U.S. health care system. Many health care providers, however, still operate on a system that generates revenue on a per-visit basis. Known in the industry as the “fee-for-service” model, this is one of the main reasons health care costs in America are as high as they are: It’s a system that rewards the volume of individual visits, procedures, and tests over quality of health outcomes. This results in what OptumCare executive vice president Jack Larsen describes as an “episodic, reactive, transactional model” in which patients are continually readmitted to the hospital.
By shifting some of the financial responsibility from insurance companies and government programs onto the shoulders of a better, more integrated, more informed delivery system, forward-thinking health care providers are moving toward a “fee-for-value” service,” which means getting patients to the right care at the right time and place, empowering patients with the education and data to make informed choices, and engaging with patients to track the value of treatments over time.
In value-based care, revenue is generated by “hitting quality standards and showing better outcomes for your particular procedure than others in your marketplace,” says Larsen. In other words, the incentives set up by the modern health care business model are designed to align with the best interest of patients and their communities.
It’s still a new approach, far from being the standard model of the U.S. health care system, but early results from those who have been using it are promising: Though it’s too early for most of systems to offer statistical proof that a coordinated care approach is an improvement, most report better outcomes, fewer ER visits, lower costs, and more satisfied patients.
A new care continuum
Many American health care professionals agree that the fee-for-service system is broken, the result of an economic model that incentivizes quantity over quality, failure to implement technology and process that facilitate information-sharing, and a system that does not take advantage of the experience of those who make it run: the physicians.
“In a non-integrated delivery system, the challenges are immense for providers and patients alike,” says Robert McBeath, M.D., CEO of OptumCare Nevada. “Much of the system in that scenario is fragmented, with poor communication and poor coordination between providers and facilities.”
The result forces doctors to spend time catching up on patients at the expense of their most important work: diagnosis and treatment. Implementing a comprehensive information and communications infrastructure that allows physicians to work better, faster, and smarter may not be easy, but, as Dr. Tamaru observes, it can “bring the joy of medicine back into the practice of medicine.”
Building a culture of health: The value proposition of retail clinics, April 2015, Robert Wood Johnson Foundation.
Medicare: House calls can help frail seniors and cut costs, June 2015, Modern Healthcare.
The cure for a doctor shortage: Primary care and teamwork, January 2016, Marketplace.
Significant Primary Care, Overall Physician Shortage Predicted by 2025, March 2015, American Academy of Family Physicians.
Better care. Smarter spending. Healthier people: Paying providers for value, not volume, January 2015, Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services.